« Previous (This week's submissions: 2005-02-14) | Main | Next (Recent submissions: 2005-02-27) »
February 26, 2005
Podcast Review: The Big Chap Podcast
This entry posted in:
3 and a half stars
, I subscribe
, Podcast Review
Format: back to back music tracks
Content: wide variety of different styles
Rating: 
What I'm going to do: I subscribe
Typical Length: 1 hour to 1 hour & 15 minutes
While I haven't written it in so many words, but I think from my previous music podcast reviews it's clear that I'm not partial to podcasts that are nothing but music. The audio/music-phile in me definitely sees that advantages of having little or no talk mixed with the music itself, and I fully apreciate the departure from the mainstream radio model of incorporating commercials and "personality" into the soundtrack that most radio stations broadcast, something in me still wants to hear something of the personality of the editor of the particular musical thread that I'm listening to. I suppose this is partly becuase when I'm listening to a music podcast I want something different than what I get from listening to a CD - I spend a fair amount of time listening to music while alone, and one of the reasons I used to turn to radio was that listening to a CD seemed lonesome, while listening to the radio provided some level of companionship. Podcasts of music without the human touch of commentary seems more along the lines of a CD. I suppose this also might be due to being conditioned by listening to the radio for so many years.
But that's enough about me. Obviously (or not so obviously, perhaps) The Big Chap Podcast is a podcast of this type. As such podcasts go, it's brought me a little closer to embracing the format of a music-only podcast. Gordon's our host here, and he puts together as varied and appealing mix of music as I've heard. Listening to The Big Chap Podcast is remeniscent (to me, at least) of getting a new mix from that friend with the really eclectic musical tastes. Listen to the Big Chap and you'll hear music you've heard before and some you've never heard. You'll hear from artists you know and ones you've never heard of. Anything from The Who to Frank Zappa to Cake to Alison Moyet to Curtis Mayfield is fair game. The music Gordon mixes matches strangely with my own varied musical tastes, and the juxtaposition between tracks lends a great deal of interest to the flow of the podcast.
Unfortunately Gordon is that friend whose musical tastes you like a lot but you don't hear from nearly as often as you'd like (like I can talk, huh?). He hasn't sent out a new podcast for nearly a month, and even the posts on his blog have been irregular. Also on the negative side, the sources that Gordon uses for his music are widely varied as far a quality; some sound great and a few less so and the volume varies somewhat, requiring some adjustment over the course of the 'cast. Gordon also doesn't concern himself with RIAA risks as far as I can see, because much of the music he 'casts is certainly freighted with RIAA licensing issues. All of this said, if the Big Chap offers up more podcasts I'll definitely be downloading them.
Meta-data is minimal (rant); I'd at least like to see the channel name in the track and file name. For the last 2 podcasts Gordon included a date-stamp, which is useful. The Big Chap Podcast is also encoded at a fairly low bit-rate (48 kbps), which means that the hour-loing podcasts are relatively small, but certainly effects the quality - since this podcast is about the music, I think a slightly higher bit-rate would be adviseable. Clearly since there's no podcaster voice in the podcast, it's unlikely that individual track lengths will be forthcoming.
Subscribe to mp3s.
Tagged: podcast podcasting review
Posted by cori at February 26, 2005 06:51 AM